Home Article “Liberty Will Never Perish” : Finding Charlie Chaplin’s Voice in an Age of Austerity

“Liberty Will Never Perish” : Finding Charlie Chaplin’s Voice in an Age of Austerity

I hadn’t heard Charlie Chaplin’s famous speech from “The Great Dictator” until today. It found me through Paolo Nutini’s haunting track “Iron Sky”, where the Scottish singer samples Chaplin’s powerful words. What began as simply enjoying a song quickly transformed into something profound when I sought out the full speech. In these turbulent times of proposed benefit cuts and growing inequality, Chaplin’s words from 1940 feel eerily prophetic.

A Speech for Our Times

“We all want to help one another. Human beings are like that. We want to live by each other’s happiness, not by each other’s misery,” Chaplin declares in his iconic address. These words, spoken as Europe descended into the darkness of fascism, resonate powerfully in today’s Britain.

The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish

When Chaplin says, “The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish”, he reminds us that the human yearning for freedom and dignity cannot be permanently extinguished. This sentiment feels particularly relevant as disabled people across Britain face what the Disability Benefits Consortium has called “cruel” cuts to vital support.

The Shifting Ground Beneath Our Feet

What strikes me about today’s political landscape is how dramatically it has shifted beneath our feet. This was perfectly captured by Dr. Stephen Watkins from Oldham in his letter to The New Statesman in 2023, which recently gained renewed attention on economist Richard Murphy’s blog.

In 60 years, I have moved from centre right to hard left without changing my opinions

“In 1962 I was a Conservative,” Dr. Watkins wrote. “I believed privilege could only be justified by service, high taxes on very high incomes were necessary to prevent an entrepreneurial economy becoming a rentier economy, and Keynesian growth would finance public service improvements and a welfare state that steadily reduced inequality… In 60 years, I have moved from centre right to hard left without changing my opinions”.

This phenomenon – known as the rightward shift of the “Overton window” – explains why policies that were once mainstream across the political spectrum are now derided as radical leftism. As Richard Murphy notes, “If you do care, you’re now on the hard left… Those things do not make you hard left. They make you a decent human being.”

I find myself wondering: when did believing in a strong social safety net become “extreme”? When did supporting disabled people to live with dignity become a controversial position? The political ground has moved so far that basic human decency is now treated as radical ideology.

The Attack on Disability Benefits

The government’s “Pathways to Work” Green Paper proposes devastating changes to disability benefits that would strip £5 billion annually from some of society’s most vulnerable people. These changes will make Personal Independence Payment (PIP) significantly harder to access, requiring claimants to score at least 4 points in a single activity rather than accumulating points across different activities.

What’s particularly concerning is how the Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, has fundamentally mischaracterised PIP when speaking before the Commons Treasury committee. She repeatedly linked PIP to employment, despite PIP being a benefit that recognises the additional costs of disability regardless of employment status.

PIP is used by many of us to stay in work and cover the extra costs that disability causes

PIP is not about work. It’s about acknowledging that being disabled in a world not built for you is expensive. Many disabled people rely on PIP to stay in employment, covering costs like specialised transport, equipment, or personal assistance. As actor Cherylee Houston powerfully stated at a recent protest: “PIP is used by many of us to stay in work and cover the extra costs that disability causes”.

When Protest Becomes a Crime

Perhaps most chillingly, these attacks on disability support coincide with an ongoing assault on our right to protest. The Crime and Policing Bill represents the fourth anti-protest bill in as many years, continuing the previous government’s authoritarian approach despite Labour’s earlier opposition to such measures.

These restrictions create a particularly dangerous situation for disabled people. If you’re seen protesting against benefit cuts, you risk being deemed “fit for work” – completely ignoring the reality that many disabled people do work, and that conditions fluctuate. The message becomes clear: stay silent or risk losing what little support remains.

As Natasha Hirst, president of the National Union of Journalists and a disabled activist, stated at a recent protest: “These proposals will take away vital financial support from disabled people, without addressing the discrimination, abuse and exclusion that we experience in our daily lives”.

Tax Wealth, Not Work

What makes this situation even more frustrating is that these cuts are a political choice, not an economic necessity. While the government slashes support for disabled people, the wealthiest in our society continue to benefit from a system designed in their favour.

Gary Stevenson, a former City trader turned inequality economist, offers a compelling alternative vision with his campaign slogan: “Tax wealth, not work”. As a founding member of Patriotic Millionaires UK, Stevenson advocates for a 1% wealth tax on wealth above £10 million.

Patriotic Millionaires UK comprises over 60 British millionaires who recognise that our economic system needs fundamental reform to address extreme wealth inequality. As member Julia Davies eloquently put it: “What’s not fair is the concentration of wealth into the hands of fewer and fewer people in the UK”.

This call for wealth taxation isn’t radical – it’s supported by 78% of voters according to a 2023 YouGov poll, including 77% of Conservative voters. It represents a growing recognition that our current system is fundamentally broken.

First They Came For…

I’m reminded of Pastor Martin Niemöller’s haunting poem about the failure to speak out against Nazi persecution. Today, we might rewrite it: “First they came for the disabled, and I did not speak out, because I was not disabled…”

The reality is that the assault on our social safety net affects us all. Today it may be PIP, tomorrow the NHS, education, or pensions. The rise of AI threatens many professional jobs once thought secure. Care needs will consume wealth in later life. The rising cost of living will strip away the experiences that make life worth living.

As Chaplin warned: “The misery that is now upon us is but the passing of greed, the bitterness of men who fear the way of human progress”. The 1% who benefit from tax breaks on unearned income from rents and investments – they are the true freeloaders in our society, not disabled people struggling to survive.

A Call to Unity

Let us all unite. Let us fight for a new world, a decent world

What we need now is solidarity. As Chaplin urged: “Let us all unite. Let us fight for a new world, a decent world”. We need those with wealth and power to recognise that their fortunes exist within a social context – that no one succeeds entirely on their own.

The Patriotic Millionaires understand this. Their mission is “to leverage the voice of wealth to build a more just, stable, and inclusive economy and to accelerate the end of extreme wealth”. They recognise that extreme inequality threatens the very foundations of our democracy.

In Chaplin’s words, “You, the people, have the power to make this life free and beautiful”. But to exercise that power, we must stand together – disabled and non-disabled, working and wealthy, young and old – against the forces of greed and division.

As we face these challenging times, let us remember Chaplin’s most powerful message: “And so long as men die, liberty will never perish”. Our resistance to injustice is what keeps freedom alive.

Angie Balmer
CEO – The Society for Neurodiversity
April 2025

Email
Print
Facebook
X
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Reddit

“Liberty Will Never Perish” : Finding Charlie Chaplin’s Voice in an Age of Austerity

I hadn’t heard Charlie Chaplin’s famous speech from “The Great Dictator” until today. It found me through Paolo Nutini’s haunting track “Iron Sky”, where the Scottish singer samples Chaplin’s powerful words. What began as simply enjoying a song quickly transformed into something profound when I sought out the full speech. In these turbulent times of proposed benefit cuts and growing inequality, Chaplin’s words from 1940 feel eerily prophetic.

Read More »

Growing Pains: A S4Nd update from CEO, Angie Balmer

Back in August 2019 I invited several autistic and otherwise neurodivergent people, their families and friends and our allies to meet with me. I wanted to know if they thought there was a need to establish an organisation that could help neurodivergent people in Calderdale and surrounding areas.

Read More »

How To Guide : Search Tool

Looking for information? The Members’ Area Search tool is powerful and a great way to find information (especially when you know what

Read More »

Leave a Comment